iPhone 11 Professional Max vs. iPhone XS Max: Smartphone Digicam Shootout
Julian Chokkattu/Digital Traits
Apple positioned an emphasis on the cameras in its new iPhone 11 Professional and iPhone 11 Professional Max smartphones, including an additional ultra-wide-angle lens whereas additionally radically enhancing the picture processing expertise, in addition to including options like an evening mode for higher low-light pictures.
How a lot of a distinction is it over final yr’s iPhone XS and XS Max? To search out out, I put the iPhone 11 Professional Max in a head-to-head digital camera shootout in opposition to the iPhone XS Max. These outcomes apply to the smaller iPhone 11 Professional and the iPhone XS as a result of they’ve the very same cameras as their bigger counterparts.
Digicam specs
On paper, the specs for the cameras on the brand new iPhone 11 Professional Max aren’t too totally different from final yr. The primary lens and telephoto lenses pack the identical 12 megapixels every on each telephones, although the telephoto on the newer iPhone has a wider f/2.zero aperture than the f/2.four on the XS Max; which means higher low-light pictures. The 2019 iPhone has an additional 12-megapixel ultra-wide-angle lens, which affords a 120-degree area of view so you’ll be able to seize a brand new perspective.
Over on the entrance, the TrueDepth digital camera system now makes use of a 12-megapixel sensor over final yr’s 7-megapixel sensor on the iPhone XS Max. Then there are the enhancements to Good HDR on the iPhone 11 Professional vary, night time mode, improved focusing pace, and semantic rendering, which altogether improves picture high quality.
These pictures had been inspected on a professionally-calibrated monitor, however on the finish of the day, pictures is subjective. Your favourite photos won’t be those I picked, and that’s okay.
Now, onto the exams!
The Excessive Line
iPhone 11 Professional Max
iPhone XS Max
Our first comparability is taken on The Excessive Line in New York Metropolis, overlooking 10th avenue. The iPhone XS Max picture is brighter, however you’ll be able to simply see the iPhone 11 Professional Max captures great colours, from the wealthy crimson bricks on the constructing to the suitable to the extra vibrant inexperienced on the leaves of the bushes. There’s extra distinction, which helps add depth to the picture, whereas the XS Max’s picture seems flat, somewhat overexposed, and pale.
Zoom in and you may see comparable ranges of element, and nearly the identical quantity of grain in darkish areas on each images. The iPhone XS Max does brighten up some darkish spots, however the total picture from the iPhone 11 Professional Max is solely superior.
Winner: iPhone 11 Professional Max
Amor
iPhone 11 Professional Max
iPhone XS Max
We’re nonetheless strolling on The Excessive Line right here, however this comparability is an effective instance of the refined modifications you’ll see in daytime pictures. The element is nearly the identical on this shot, however the colours throughout the board are boosted, leading to a barely extra dynamic picture.
These darker colours imply deeper blacks, once more including extra depth to the iPhone 11 Professional Max’s picture, which is somewhat hotter too. These are all tweaks I’d most likely make to the iPhone XS Max’s picture, however with the Professional, it’s a photograph that’s able to be shared proper after it’s captured.
Winner: iPhone 11 Professional Max
Telephoto lens: empty avenue
iPhone 11 Professional Max
iPhone XS Max
The iPhone XS Max typically makes an attempt to brighten up an entire picture, and that’s greatest seen right here. It’s a pleasant picture, however examine it with the iPhone 11 Professional Max’s picture and you may see precisely how a lot it has stripped away the shadows. These shadows assist make the iPhone 11 Professional Max’s picture look extra fascinating, capturing extra distinction, whereas the iPhone XS Max’s shot is flat.
Particulars are possibly a hair stronger on the Professional’s picture, and colours are somewhat extra pure too, with much less of a hotter tone. You too can see a little bit of the blue sky on the iPhone 11 Professional Max’s shot, whereas it’s blown out on the XS Max.
Winner: iPhone 11 Professional Max
Evening Mode: the canine park
iPhone 11 Professional Max
iPhone XS Max
Low gentle is the place we begin to see extra dramatic modifications, and that’s due to the brand new automated Evening mode that kicks in on the iPhone 11 vary when the digital camera detects poor lighting. It’s an extended publicity, and infrequently you’ll see the digital camera advocate a Three- to 2-second publicity, which does imply you’ll want to remain as nonetheless as potential to keep away from a blurry shot. You possibly can flip Evening mode off and you too can go for a most long-exposure, which varies primarily based on the lighting you’re in. There’s no such Evening mode on the iPhone XS Max.
On this picture on the canine park, you’ll be able to see the iPhone 11 Professional Max’s picture is impressively brighter, displaying off the twilight blue coloration of the sky, which is nearly invisible within the iPhone XS Max’s picture. Every part within the scene is illuminated extra, and the bushes, fences, buildings within the background are seen.
You possibly can see that as a result of it’s a long-exposure the husky operating on the suitable is a blur, and for those who zoom in intently on the bench, you’ll be able to see it’s ever-so-slightly blurry. The iPhone XS Max’s is sharper, and that’s as a result of it’s capturing quicker. My fingers can solely be so nonetheless, which suggests you’ll see higher-quality pictures for those who use a tripod and use Evening mode on the iPhone 11 Professional Max.
Nonetheless, even with it being somewhat blurrier than the iPhone XS Max picture, I’d share the iPhone 11 Professional Max’s picture as a result of it’s brighter total and extra visually fascinating.
Winner: iPhone 11 Professional Max
Evening Mode: Doorway to the bar
iPhone 11 Professional Max
iPhone XS Max
Right here’s one other good instance that showcases the enhancements Evening mode brings to low-light pictures. The iPhone 11 Professional Max’s picture is brighter total, sustaining a variety of colours, making for a extra fascinating picture than the one from the iPhone XS Max. Zoom in on the door and also you’ll see much less grain, too.
Maybe extra shocking is that I used to be in a position to maintain the iPhone 11 Professional Max with out shaking a lot as a result of it’s sharper and extra detailed than the iPhone XS Max’s picture (which took a very long time to correctly autofocus). Look intently on the crimson signal in the back of the bar, and it’s far simpler to learn “No smoking, no vaping,” than on the iPhone XS Max.
Winner: iPhone 11 Professional Max
Telephoto lens: Zooming at midnight
iPhone 11 Professional Max
iPhone XS Max
Sadly, Evening mode solely works on the principle digital camera, although if the principle digital camera thinks digitally cropping a picture with the principle digital camera as a substitute of utilizing the telephoto lens at night time will web you a greater picture, then it would use it (and Evening mode) whenever you faucet on the 2x signal. That being mentioned, the telephoto lens on the iPhone 11 Professional Max does supply up extra detailed and colourful images at night time as a result of it has a wider aperture, permitting the lens to absorb extra gentle.
This zoomed-in picture of Gimbel’s Bridge in Midtown Manhattan exhibits the distinction. Look intently on the copper construction, and also you’ll see particulars proper right down to the high quality traces. It’s a blurry, grainy mess on the iPhone XS Max’s picture. The colours are bolder, making the picture pop extra, and the leaves within the foreground are literally individually seen, quite than the garbled mess on the XS Max.
Winner: iPhone 11 Professional Max
Portrait Mode: Extra choices
iPhone 11 Professional Max, 2X
iPhone XS Max
iPhone 11 Professional Max, 1X
Portrait Mode has additionally improved on the iPhone 11 Professional, however maybe most vital is the truth that now you can take Portrait Mode pictures with the principle lens as a substitute of getting to depend on the telephoto lens (faucet the 2X button on the left whenever you go to Portrait within the digital camera). By switching to the principle lens, the digital camera isn’t so zoomed into the topic, nevertheless it additionally means you’ll be able to benefit from the broader aperture, leading to a brighter picture that’s much less grainy.
The primary picture on the high is Portrait Mode on the iPhone 11 Professional Max with the usual 2x possibility, utilizing the telephoto lens. It’s good, capturing good particulars and colours. The iPhone XS Max picture comes subsequent, and it’s not dangerous, however you’ll be able to see extra grain on the woman’s face, and the surroundings within the background is way darker. The final picture is from the iPhone 11 Professional Max, and it’s utilizing the principle digital camera. It allowed me to seize the woman’s outfit extra than simply her face (with out shifting positions), and all the things seems sharper, brighter, and colours look positively wonderful. It’s a improbable shot.
It must be famous that the blur high quality is impeccable on all these images, as is the accuracy of the impact across the topic; there are hardly any errors. However the iPhone 11 Professional Max takes the cake for its extra pleasing images, and the additional versatility.
Winner: iPhone 11 Professional Max
Portrait Mode: Extremely-low gentle
iPhone 11 Professional Max, 2X
iPhone XS Max
Right here’s a extra drastic instance. The underside picture has been my expertise utilizing Portrait Mode on the iPhone XS Max in low-light conditions; the standard has all the time been poor. You possibly can barely see something on this picture, and it’s not value speaking about rather more. The iPhone 11 Professional Max’s portrait mode picture isn’t good, nevertheless it’s immensely higher and shareable.
Colours are distinctive, regardless of the general heat tone, the blur impact seems actually good and hair isn’t reduce off anyplace. Certain, the woman’s face is grainy, however that is nonetheless a shocking picture for Portrait Mode at night time and a drastic enchancment over final yr’s iPhone.
Winner: iPhone 11 Professional Max
Selfies: Portrait Mode
1.
iPhone 11 Professional Max
2.
iPhone XS Max
The 12-megapixel digital camera on the entrance is best than the 7-megapixel selfie digital camera on the iPhone XS Max. Do word, that by default capturing selfies in portrait orientation will web you a 7-megapixel cropped picture; you’ll be able to take a full 12-megapixel shot if you’d like a bunch selfie or extra of the background by tapping the zoom out button above the shutter.
The comparability above is with Portrait Mode on the entrance digital camera, and the iPhone 11 Professional Max simply takes the cake. Zoom in towards the nostril and you may see it’s simply quite a bit sharper, brighter, and extra detailed. My face nearly seems squished on the XS Max’s picture.
Winner: iPhone 11 Professional Max
Video enhancements
There are video enhancements on the iPhone 11 Professional Max as nicely. Each can shoot at 4K 60 frames per second for high-quality footage, however stabilization is somewhat higher, and the prolonged dynamic vary on the iPhone 11 Professional Max permits for better-exposed movies.
Extremely wide-angle digital camera
And that is all with out even speaking in regards to the iPhone 11 Professional Max’s ultra-wide-angle digital camera, which permits for lots extra artistic pictures. It’s inconceivable to match it to the iPhone XS Max, which doesn’t have an ultra-wide-angle lens, however check out a number of the images above to see what you are able to do with it.
Wrap-up: and the winner is…
The iPhone 11 Professional Max. It’s hardly a shock new telephone takes higher images than its predecessor, however there are some substantial modifications right here that warrant these feeling hampered by the digital camera on the iPhone XS and iPhone XS Max to improve to Apple’s newest, significantly with low-light pictures, which matches if not surpasses the competitors.
Editors’ Suggestions
